Showing posts with label For Photographers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label For Photographers. Show all posts

Friday, December 17, 2010

Two of the Most Giving, Open-Hearted People I Know: Jed & Vicki Taufer

Today I want to talk about a couple of people that I find truly inspirational and that I look up to so much! They are the kind of people I aspire to be on a regular basis. Vicki and Jed Taufer, if you don't know them, own the V Gallery in Morton, IL, which is one of the top portrait studios in the country. But Vicki and Jed are more than just a photography team, they are a couple of the most giving people I know. These two are constantly giving back to the photography community. In addition to the multiple workshops and seminars that Vicki & Jed speak at, they also started V Gallery Haven to help photographers through their own workshops and various products to help them with workflow, marketing, etc.

Most importantly though, Vicki and Jed are amazing people! Just being in the same room with them for more than a minute, you just feel an overwhelming sense of peace, acceptance, and genuineness. These two have maintained an unbelievable amount of optimism and trust in the Lord despite their difficult circumstances. I'd like to take a few minutes to share their struggle with you in hopes that you may be willing to take a few minutes to do what you can to help these amazing people.

Meet Nima!
Photo by Vicki Taufer
Isn't she the sweetest little girl ever?!  Jed and Vicki adopted Nima in August this year from Nepal, which is one of the poorest countries in the world and has around a million orphans and abandoned children. 
Photo courtesy of Vicki Taufer
Okay so here's a little background on Nepal. Nepal has around a million orphans and abandoned children. In Nepal, pre-marital sex is illegal so women who get pregnant outside of wed-lock often abandon their children and try very hard to remain anonymous, which makes it incredibly difficult to prove a child is an orphan or abandoned.
Photo by Vicki Taufer
The Nepalese government recognizes Vicki and Jed as Nima's legal parents. The problem is with the policy change the U.S. government is making it very difficult to get a visa for children who were abandoned. They are basically stating that all documents belonging to children listed as "abandoned' are to be assumed false and must be investigated and followed up on thoroughly in order to prove the child was really abandoned thereby validating the information of said documents.

Photo by Vicki Taufer

I can't even imagine the pain of not being able to bring your child home with you! To have spent months, years planning and getting everything ready for the big day. To hold your child in your arms, see her smile at you, snuggle into your chest. To fall in love with your child and see her connect with you. And then be told that even though you are legally her parents, you can't bring her home!
Photo by Vicki Taufer
Vicki has been living in Nepal with her beautiful little girl and Jed has been here in the States working. They have had to hire a private investigator and a lawyer to prove that Nima truly was abandoned and hopefully be able to bring her home. Vicki and Jed are optimistic and hopeful that they may be able to get Nima's visa and bring her home in January.

Photo courtesy of Vicki Taufer
As I'm sure you can guess, this whole process has been emotionally and financially exhausting. With Vicki stranded in Nepal until the U.S. government decides to grant Nima a visa, she hasn't been home to work at the studio. If you are in a position to help with their financial situation right now, I would greatly encourage you to do so. I absolutely cannot think of a more deserving family. Just head over to nimajade.com and click on the donate button.

Another way you can help this couple and all those in a similar situation over in Nepal is by copying the letter below and sending it to your selected officials. There is also this website (http://www.petition2congress.com/3867/bring-stranded-nepali-adoptees-home-now/) that has a petition you can sign and then gives you this same letter with the list of politicians for your area based on your zip code.

To Whom It May Concern,
We are aware of a group of Americans who have recently traveled to Nepal in order to pick up children they have adopted and bring them home. Upon arriving, they've discovered that the U.S. has changed their policy regarding adoption in Nepal and now they are stuck in a situation where it looks very doubtful that they are going to be able to bring their babies home. There are currently 12 families whose voices need to be heard and collectively we can make a difference if we act now.


Please help us fight this injustice by looking into the case and taking immediate action. These families need their adoptions to be processed under the previous investigation policies that were in effect just a week or so ago so they can bring their children home. Contact Ruth Lincoln at the Office of Children's Issues within the Bureau of Consular Affairs - lincolnra@state.gov or anyone else who may be able to resolve this issue as soon as possible. If you'd like to contact one of the members of the 12 families, feel free to email jedness@mac.com.
Thank you for your efforts.

I hope the Taufer's story touches and inspires you. I know I feel truly blessed to have met these wonderful people. Jed and Vicki have supported and inspired me in ways they don't even know, and I strive on a daily basis to be more like them. Giving, open-hearted, and faith-filled.
Photo by Vicki Taufer
Please keep Jed, Vicki, and Nima in your thoughts and prayers! Any support you can provide will be greatly appreciated! And Jed, Vicki - thank you so much for getting back to me so quickly and letting me share your story. I've truly meant every word that I've written, and I love you both for just being you, sharing yourself, your love, and your passion with all of us. This world would be a far better place if there were more people in it like you. :)

Contact Me | Visit My Website | Join the Facebook Fan Page | Follow Me on Twitter


P.S. If you'd like to read the full story - you can find it here: http://www.vgallery.net/letter/

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Escalate 2010 | Julia Woods' Talk | Washington, IL

The last speaker at Escalate Live was Julia Woods (who actually just won wedding image of the year from PPA Photo Asia). Julia and Jeffrey Woods own Portrait Life Studio in Washington IL and have won multiple awards for their work.

Julia talked about the business side of photography, which is the side of my business I've needed to learn the most about. This first thing Julia had us do was figure out what we want out of our business. She said the first thing on that list should be making money....after all - you are a business. Honestly, before she said that, I had lost sight of the fact that I was running a business. It doesn't make me a bad person because I want (no need) to make money - it makes me a good business person. This thought alone has really pushed me to make the changes that will be taking effect come January 1st (to stay up to date on my changes sign up for the newsletter). Obviously the second and third items on this list are a Happy Client and a Creative Outlet.


In the picture below you can see one of the unique products Julia and Jeffrey provide. This is a iPad wedding album. The cover of the box has an iPad that plays a photo video of their wedding images and inside the box is their printed wedding album. This is what successful photographers are doing in their own businesses. They are providing their clients with products or services that are unique and different from other photographers in the area.

The other thing Jeffrey and Julia do is they sell the product first - before the session ever starts. This way you can take pictures that are going to fulfill their needs perfectly. For example, let's say your clients wants a photo collection for their wall over their couch. If you know what exactly it is they are looking for - you can go into the session knowing what you need to capture for their specific wants and needs. This is definitely something I'm going to be moving towards.


After Julia's lecture - she did her little mini-session with this beautiful girl. And I love this lens! Look how huge it is!


It was really neat to see how Julia works. It's completely different from how I do my sessions so it was definitely a learning experience for me.




I hope you enjoyed seeing what I learned from Julia. You should really check out her work! You can see samples of it on her blog at http://www.jeffreyandjuliawoods.com/blog/


Contact Me | Visit My Website | Join the Facebook Fan Page | Follow Me on Twitter

Tuesday, November 9, 2010

Escalate 2010 | Tamara Lackey's Talk | Washington, IL

Today I'm going to cover some of things I learned from Tamara Lackey at Escalate Live. I have followed Tamara's blog for at least a year now. Tamara is an award winning children's photographer based in North Carolina. Tamara captures these beautiful spontaneous moments and expressions and has a unique shooting style, which is similar to how I work. So I was excited to hear what Tamara had to say!

Tamara actually covered a bit of the technical side of shooting. So for some of you non-photographers this may be a little less than interesting to read. ;)

Something I think all photographers can agree on is that it's important to know your camera and how to get good exposures so that when that perfect moment happens you aren't fiddling with dials and buttons. Too often those neat little moments that occur when people aren't being told what to do are missed because the photographer isn't 1) looking for the shot or 2) trying to make adjustments. So basically the idea is to know your camera and how it works so that shooting is just instinctual. This was a nice little reminder for Tamara to bring up and has encouraged me to always stay on top of understanding how my camera works.


The next thing Tamara covered was lighting. I can't even tell you how many shoots I've gone on where the client mentions that we had great lighting for the shoot. So I feel like it's a pretty safe assumption to say that everyone knows how important lighting is to creating a great picture. However, there is a lot more to the lighting of a picture than a lot of people realize. Here's just a thought on that - Photography is oftentimes called painting with light....if that's the case (and it is) just think how important lighting actually is.

Okay so here's a few thoughts on lighting. In every picture a photographer considers these four sources of light and how to utilize them for your photo:
1) Main Light - In an outdoor setting this would be the sun.
2) Fill Light - For outdoor photos this would actually be the shade. It's what creates depth to an image.
3) Hair Light - This kind of light occurs when someone is backlit. So if the sun was behind you.
4) Ambient Light - This is exactly what it sounds like. Just the natural light that comes into an image.
So in every picture that is taken all four of these kinds of lights need to be considered and utilized properly to create an overall strong shot.

Tamara also covered the six different personality types that are found in children (and sometimes adults). Knowing these different personality types and being able to spot what type of personality your subject has makes it ten times easier to figure out how to interact with them and get those pictures that reflect the child's personality and also make mom happy. So here's a quick run-down of the six different personality types and how to interact with them.
1) The Super Star - these kids want to be photographed and love to "cheese" for the camera. They are up for anything so feel free to experiment
2) The Shy One - This child is much more reserved. Focus on getting beautiful, soft, dreamy images.
3) The Interactive One - This child is incredibly inquisitive and interested. Become someone they can interact with.
4) The One Who Just Needs to Warm Up -Some kids just need time to get adjusted to you. Be sure to give them whatever amount of time they need to feel comfortable with you.
5) The Spirited Child - You can get a wide variety of shots from this child. They may be a bit ornery so be prepared. And always be sure to walk them through everything your doing. This way they feel involved in the whole process and are more prone to play along instead of rebel.
6) The Sick, Tired, Tantrumy Child - Try to avoid a sick child at all costs! Shooting a sick child isn't fun for the photographer or the child. If the child is tired. Try to get them excited about something.

Now for some pics from Tamara's little mini-session:








If you are interested in seeing more of Tamara's work or getting some of her educational material - check out her website at: http://www.tamaralackeyblog.com/

Contact Me | Visit My Website | Join the Facebook Fan Page | Follow Me on Twitter

Tuesday, November 2, 2010

Escalate 2010 | Lori Nordstrom's Talk | Washington, IL

I was really interested to hear what Lori Nordstrom was going to talk about. Lori is from Iowa and specializes in baby photography. And I'll be honest - I haven't had a whole lot of opportunities to work with babies so I knew it was an area that I could learn a lot about. And let me tell you...did I ever!!!

Lori covered a lot of things in her talk from marketing to specialized products to a newborn studio necessity list. It honestly would be really hard to cover all the things she talked about here. So I'm going to focus on some of the most beneficial and interesting things I learned.


As with everyone else at Escalate Live, Lori stressed the importance of figuring out who you are, what makes you different and how to set yourself apart. The kind of photography that I, we, do isn't just about creating pictures or even providing a service...it goes a step beyond that. We take time to get to know you. To find out what you want and need and try to create that something to best fit you and your home. We aren't some department store photo studio...we don't plop you down, snap a few shots, and kick you out in 30 minutes or less. That's not what we are about. Anyway...back to the things I learned.

Seeing as I haven't done a whole lot of baby sessions and I don't have any children of my own yet, Lori taught me some things that I wouldn't have known otherwise. For example, the best newborn pictures are captured within the first 10 days of life. This is when baby is the sleepiest and you can move them into cute little poses and positions that become more difficult they older they get. These photos are also primarily taken in the nude and with baby's eyes shut. I also learned that it's important to let your moms know that "your child will poop, pee, and throw up on my things, and I am fully prepared for that. So don't you worry about it. Just bring something along that we can use to clean baby up." Just letting mom know that she can expect this to happen, puts her a little more ease and she'll be less worried or concerned if her child has an accident during the session. Here's a quick picture that Lori snapped during her mini-session at Escalate Live:


The next session would be the 4 month old session. By this time, most children have become very expressive. This a great opportunity to get as many different pictures of baby's expressions as possible. Then mom has a kaleidoscope of the many different faces their child has made and it could be made into a nine-up piece or a photo book. This is also about the time that baby starts pushing up with their arms when they are laying on their belly. So it's a great opportunity to get a couple shots of that new development. Here's a sample of a 4-up piece showing baby's expressions (pics taken at Escalate Live too):

By 8 months, baby is sitting up, maybe pulling himself/herself up, so it's the perfect chance to get some fun pictures of this. Baby is also highly reactive and you can start to play with him/her to get some fun reaction shots or even just some pictures of the baby playing with toys. These can make an awesome storyboard piece or (again) an excellent photo book.

At one year, most moms are interested in doing a birthday cake session. Just strip baby down to his/her diaper and let them have at their own personal birthday cake. You can get some super fun shots of baby smashing a smearing cake and icing on themselves or the floor.

The other thing I learned from Lori is talking to your clients about a Design session. Basically what this is viewing session to help them fit their needs. It covers everything from photo videos, photo books, prints, and wall art. They even have the client send them a photo of the wall they are imagining putting a wall portrait on with a yardstick somewhere in the photo. Then they use the pictures the client likes and using photoshop put together what a framed piece of art might look like on that particular wall in their house.

But the most important thing I learned from Lori was patience. When Lori set up to do her photo session of a little one month old baby, I was just so impressed to see how calm and patient she was. That stubborn little girl just did not want to sleep. But Lori just sat their with her hand holding the baby's legs in the position she wanted them in and just sat there...and waited. I'm the first to admit I'm not the most patient person in the world. But after watching how Lori did that...I feel like I could be patient enough to do that for newborn photos too. Here's just a few pictures of Lori working with the little baby. :)


P.S. I want a big chunky blanket like that so bad! It's just super cool and a great texture...



Well I hope you enjoyed seeing a little bit more of what I learned from Escalate Live. There will be another installment next week starring Tamara Lackey. If you've got anything you'd like to add or share, feel free to leave me a comment.

Contact Me | Visit My Website | Join the Facebook Fan Page | Follow Me on Twitter

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Escalate 2010 | Julianne Kost's Talk | Washington, IL

I thought I might share a little about the next speaker at the Escalate Live event on the blog today. Her name is Julianne Kost and she is an awesome individual! Julianne makes really beautiful and interesting photographic composites. She works for Adobe, and is one of the creators for the adobe software (so she's incredibly smart). Top that all off with great comedic timing and a fantastic sense of humor and Julianne is one awesome package!



As a regular on Adobe TV, dishing out advice and tips on how to use the Adobe products, Julianne's talk was largely about how to best utilize the software you have for optimum efficiency and ease. I was really interested to hear what she had to say because I've been doing my work the same way for...well...forever. When I started up the business I bought Adobe CS3 and I was so excited and proud to own my own copy. Creative Suite 5 is the current Adobe package that is available so I'm not too terribly far behind the times. But after seeing some of the things you can do with CS5...I'm yearning for the days when I'll own a copy.

I also got to learn a little about Lightroom. Lightroom is another Adobe product geared towards photographers. I have not used Lightroom yet, I use Aperture and Photoshop...leaning much more heavily on Photoshop. But I do see the benefits of using a program like Lightroom. And maybe one day in the future that will be another program I will add to my post-processing arsenal.


But one of the things Julianne said that I plan on putting into effect for myself is to ..." always have at least one personal long-term project. Not business related but for yourself." I think this is really good advice. We so often get so caught up in work that we forget to take a little time for ourselves. I don't know what my personal project will be...we'll just have to see.

So there you have it! A little about Julianne Kost and what I learned from her. Check back tomorrow to catch a sneak peek of Marcy & Mike's engagement pictures!

Contact Me | Visit My Website | Join the Facebook Fan Page | Follow Me on Twitter

Tuesday, September 7, 2010

Labor Day Weekend Wedding

We had a busy weekend over Labor Day weekend. I had both an engagement shoot and a wedding scheduled for the weekend. With all the new information I have been learning from Jasmine Star and the creativeLIVE team, I was super excited to start using some of it for the wedding on Sunday. So what did I apply to shooting Jennifer & Chris's wedding?

Well I decided to take control this time. Ryan and I arrived at the site and I found the location I wanted to use for the First Look. Then I scoped out the outdoor environment for the best spot for the group photos. The church was very dark inside and I know I am my most confident when I'm allowed to do outdoor photos. So I took control of that situation by suggesting that we do as many group photos outside as possible.

I also heeded the idea of doing everything possible to create the best photo in camera. I removed clutter. I grabbed things I wanted pictures of and took them to an ideal location. I fixed hair and dresses and collars. And flipping through the pictures later - I can already tell I have significantly decreased my post processing time.

I initiated conversations with both the preacher and the dj (at the reception) to make sure we were all on the same page and keeping on schedule. This is something I normally do anyway, but it was something that Jasmine reiterated during her lectures and so I made extra sure to do so on Sunday. The DJ, Mr. Troy Armstrong from Jacksonville IL, was fabulous! He is hands-down one of the best DJ's I have had the pleasure of working with to date.

Now lighting. I meant to get a pin light to bring with me, but in the chaos that was my weekend forgot to bring it. Thankfully - the groom's boss had a nice little LED light in his car and let me use it to take some detail shots. He was a life saver. It was just too dark to get a great macro lens shot of the rings without it. Here's one example:

As for the rest of the reception - I think I pulled it off pretty well. It was a very dark venue and I was having some issues with the mirrors on the walls. They would pick up my flash in the image and leave the pictures very dark. I did find a way to work around them though and did great for only having my on-camera flash to use. In the future I would like to have a secondary light source like Jasmine talks about. All things in time.

All in all - it was another wedding full of learning experiences for me. I'm so happy for Jen and Chris and I hope they are having a blast on their honeymoon.

Check in tomorrow to see pictures from Gina & Jason's Engagement session.

Contact Me | Visit My Website | Join the Facebook Fan Page | Follow Me on Twitter

Wednesday, August 4, 2010

Wedding Photo Competition

Well I was looking through my twitter message board the other day and I noticed that Digital Photo Buzz is having another photo competition. (Click here to view the contest page.) This time it's focusing on wedding photography and I'm so happy with the pictures I took at Meagan and Joe's wedding that I thought I would submit one. The trouble is I can't decide which one to submit. I'm torn between these two pictures:
Picture 1

Picture 2
I would love to get your input as to which picture you think is the stronger image! Please answer the poll below. Thanks a bunch!






Monday, July 19, 2010

The Power of the Macro

Back in May I did some senior photos for a handsome young man over in St. Louis. I was blessed to meet his mother who happens to makes some absolutely amazing jewelry. I kid you not - her creations look like something you would buy at a high end store. They are gorgeous! But she mentioned that she would love to put together a catalog of her pieces to be able to pass out or show to potential buyers. I thought this was a fabulous idea and I was thrilled when she asked me if I would be interested. 
So when I got the money together I invested in a new lens to help me better show off her work: the Canon 100mm Macro Lens. In case you don't know this about me…I get very excited when I get new equipment. So the minute I got home I had to test it out to see what it could do. I have to admit I was pretty giddy for the rest of the afternoon and so I thought I'd share some pictures with you so you could see too.
Size 5 Ring from Target...You can see all the detail in the wire

Here's another view of the same ring even closer

This one shows the shallow depth of field. You can see how only a very select area is in focus in this picture.

Not only can you see the nicks in my size 4.5 wedding band, but you can see the fuzz caught on the diamond.

This photo is of my phone with my standard lens...then...

This is of the same phone with my macro lens. Again you can see the shallow depth of field.

I just love this little sculpture, but you can see how the background is soft focused.

I figured this would give a real concept of it's abilities. Here's a dime's face. (Don't you love the deep gouges in my wood floor...that's what you get when you have a very excitable puppy.)

If that last one didn't do it for you - check this out. You can easily see the ridges on the side of the dime. 
Well there you have it. Some sample photos of what the lovely Macro lens can do! :)

Tuesday, July 13, 2010

New Website

Well it's official. The new site is live on the web. I'm still making tweaks and there will be a couple of changes over the next few months. So feel free to check it out and give me your feedback. I'd love to hear what you think of it - good and bad. :)
But what I wanted to show you is the video I put together on my own for the photography home page(http://greentreemediaonline.com/photo_main.html). Here it is:

I made this video using Animoto.com. It was super easy to make and actually I found it fun to put together. It is also surprisingly affordable. They have packages ranging from free to $250 per year depending on what you want. So there you have it photography fans - a new way for you to present your images. :)

Thursday, June 17, 2010

Canon Macro Lens vs. Tamron Macro Lens

So I'm looking into getting a macro lens for my camera. I feel that it would be super beneficial to have one for taking pictures of wedding rings, jewelry, and some specific commercial work I've been asked to do. So I started looking into finding one and I found this article comparing the tamron lens to the canon lens and found it very thorough and helpful so I thought I would share what I found with all of you. (All information and images were taken from: http://photo.net/equipment/canon/can-tam-macro/)

Canon EF 100mm f/2.8 Macro USM vs Tamron SP Autofocus 90mm f/2.8 DI Macro Lens

by Richard Harris

Due to the fact that in many (but not all) markets the Tamron 90mm f/2.8 Macro is substantially cheaper than the Canon EF 100mm f/2.8 Macro USM the question as to how the two lenses compare seems to crop up extremely often on the photo.net boards. What’s more, as an owner of the third party offering I have often wondered how it compares to the Canon lens. Like many others before me I have occasionally toyed with the idea of upgrading one day, however instead I decided to rent the Canon lens and do a side by side comparison. The tests were carried out with my EOS 10D and all the samples shown are unprocessed and straight from the camera.

Both lenses have excellent reputations however the Canon lens is generally considered to be the better product, so I was very curious to see just how much there is between them.

Handling

The Canon lens is the larger and heavier of the two, and it’s front element is exposed right at the front of the lens, whilst the Tamron’s front element is very deeply recessed inside the lens barrel. This presumably has the effect of shielding it from flare without the supplied lens hood being fitted, however it does reduce the effective working distance from the subject a little since there is an extra couple of centimetres beyond the front element.

The Canon should always be fitted with its optional (and expensive) lens hood, since the front element has absolutely no protection from stray light without this.

In terms of handling, the Canon is the obvious winner since it has USM and FTM. Autofocus is quick and accurate, although not quite as fast as with my 300F4 L. This relative (and slight) slowness is probably down to the enormous focusing range, from 1:1 to infinity. Remarkably, the lens seems to autofocus right down to it’s minimum focusing distance fairly reliably, meaning that it is feasible for AF to be used for macro work. Obviously in most cases manual focus will still be best when working at high magnification, but I can see where AF might be useful with moving subjects.

The Tamron’s AF performance, while not on a par with the Canon, is also pretty good. AF is fast but slightly noisy (no USM motor here), however it is only effective at longer ranges, at close range the AF hunts a lot and often fails to lock on. For macro work with this lens manual focus is the only viable option. The Tamron also does not have FTM, instead it uses a clutch mechanism on the focusing ring itself to switch between AF and MF. This system works well enough but is not as easy or ergonomic as Canon’s full time manual focusing.

Both lenses have excellent manual focusing rings, which are easy and pleasant to use. I personally prefer the smaller build and lighter weight of the Tamron lens, but overall the Canon is a much better mechanical design.

Sharpness

For this test the lenses were mounted on a tripod and a cable release was used. I was very careful to check for accurate focus before each shot.

The lenses have different focal lengths, in this test though I did not try and compensate for this by moving the camera forward, it seemed more logical to keep it in the same spot and simply ignore the difference in magnification. It is still perfectly possible to judge the performance of both lenses despite this difference.

This is what the full image looks like:

lens test image

Below is a 100% crop from the centre portion of the frame, in each case the Tamron sample is on the left, the Canon is on the right. No post processing has been done, these images are straight off the camera.

F2.8 F2.8
F5.6 F5.6
F8 F8
F16 F16

Next up is a sample from the corners, again the Tamron is on the left, the Canon is on the right:

F2.8 F2.8
F5.6 F5.6
F8 F8
F16 F16

It seems to me to be a dead heat, in this test at least. Both lenses perform very similarly, they are very slightly soft and dull at F2.8, but sharpness and contrast improve by F5.6, F8 doesn’t seem any different but by F16 there is some softness creeping back in. The corners are slightly softer than the centre, but performance seems to still be excellent in both cases.

I have a feeling this result may well upset a few Canonites, but there it is. Both lenses are clearly excellent and the Tamron lens can quite easily match its more expensive cousin, even wide open. Results on a higher resolution full frame camera might well be more revealing, but on my EOS 10D at least there seems to be very little between the two in terms of sharpness and contrast.

High magnification

disclaimer: This test was carried out for the sake of completeness, it wouldn't make sense testing macro lenses without some high magnification samples. However there are many problems with any test done at a magnification close to 1:1, simply because it is extremely difficult to focus with 100% accuracy at this level of magnification and depth of field is so extremely shallow that the slightest focusing error would render the test meaningless. In the light of this I will state that this test should only be viewed as representative of my own efforts and should not be held as being a guaranteed benchmark.

For this test I mounted the camera on a Gitzo Explorer tripod, set up a 550EX to the side of the subject and connected the camera to my computer via USB. To ensure the best possible focus I used angle finder C to manually focus and then took a series of test frames with focus bracketing which were then compared on the computer screen at 100%, and the focus was fine tuned until it was as good as I could get it. Mirror lockup and a cable release were used, although using the 550EX as the lightsource should help to minimise vibration problems anyway.

I also tried autofocus but at this magnification it wasn't reliable enough to give results that could be used usefully in a lens test. While the Canon lens autofocused far more reliably at this magnification than the Tamron ever could, manual focusing proved to be much more accurate still (AF was always slightly soft in comparison). I presume that the tolerances for AF just aren't fine enough for such demanding conditions as are encountered at 1:1.

Sample image

This is the full frame, a coin taken close to 1:1.

These are 100% crops from the centre of the image:

F2.8 F2.8
F4 F4
F5.6 F5.6
F8 F8
F16 F16

Interestingly, although the Canon lens appears to be very slightly sharper wide-open, once the lenses are stopped down a little the Tamron seems to have far better contrast, colour and detail. Contrast from the Canon lens doesn't really catch up until F8, which seems to be the sweet spot for that lens, while the Tamron actually seems best at F5.6. At F16 both lenses lose some sharpness due to diffraction although the Tamron still appears slightly sharper.

While these results can't be held as being conclusive, it does appear as if the Tamron is the better lens for macro work. One caveat being of course that lens sharpness is one of many variables for this type of work, and indeed typical macro apertures will be around F16 where both lenses have lost some resolution. At this level most shooters will have enough problems with depth of field and focusing to lose too much sleep over minor differences in lens sharpness.

To illustrate this point here is a 50% sample of the F16 files with unsharp mask applied, as you can see the differences are still visible but very subtle, and sharpness is very good. The Tamron lens does undeniably show more detail though.

F16 @ 50%

F16 @ 50% USM applied.

I would also have liked to show some corner samples to give an idea of corner sharpness and the flat field ability of each lens, but unfortunately this wasn't possible as I don't have the means of guaranteeing that my samples were parallel with the film plane. At these magnifications there is no room for error, and the only way I could guarantee that what was being tested was the lenses as opposed to my ability to line up the subjects with the film plane would be with a precision made copy stand - which is an item I don't own.

Bokeh, colour and flare

Here is a close up sequence comparing both lenses at varying apertures, again the Tamron is on the left and the Canon on the right:

F2.8F2.8
F4F4
F5.6F5.6
F8F8

Some general notes: in both cases colour and contrast visibly improve by F4, but the Canon lens has a warmer colour balance and more saturated colours. Bokeh seems very similar with both lenses in this particular test. It’s smooth and pleasing, the Tamron’s may be ever so slightly softer.

This following sequence was designed to test both bokeh and flare resistance:

F2.8F2.8
F4F4
F5.6F5.6
F8F8
F16F16
F32F32

Unfortunately there appears to be about 1/3 of stop difference in exposure between these two sequences, which makes colour differences unreliable. Having said that the Canon does seem to hold detail better in the brightest parts, beneath the flame of the nearest candle.

Bokeh is again very similar with both lenses, wide open both have a pleasing rendition of the highlights. Stopped down the Canon has a nicer star pattern on the highlights, with fewer points arranged in a neater pattern.

Wide open the Canon has a tiny bit of flare by the nearest flame, however stopped down this seems to disappear. The Tamron however seems to suffer from very visible flare artefacts when stopped down. This is the only really disappointing result so far from the Tamron lens, and gives an indication of why that front element is so deeply recessed. The Canon is a definite and dramatic improvement in terms of flare control.

I have also tried a couple of other tests pointing the lenses straight at light sources and both do actually seem to resist flare pretty well in most circumstances, these are full frames:

Sun @ F32

Sun @ F32

Lightbulb @ F32

Lightbulb @ F32

Working Distance, focal length and background control

For this test, I measured the working distance from the front of the lens housing (not the front element itself or the film plane like in many tests) to the point of focus at maximum magnification. The Canon has 15cm (just under 6 inches) free between the front of the lens and the subject, while the Tamron only has 11cm (just over four and a quarter inches). The Tamron lens is actually 2.5cm (1 inch) inside the housing, which could have yielded more working distance had the lens been designed differently, but obviously Tamron decided flare control was a more important issue than working distance.

Both these measurements were done without lens hoods on, if you fit a hood to the Tamron it will almost touch your subject at 1:1, the Canon has a little more clearance. Working distance is only really an issue with live subjects such as insects, however it is important to many macro shooters and if you are one of those who needs as much distance as possible the Canon lens is the better choice.

There is however one situation where less working distance is actually a good thing, which is working with flash at high magnifications. The closer your flashgun is to the subject, the softer the light. If you have an external flashgun mounted on a bracket over or near your lens, or a unit such as an MT24-EX, every inch closer that the flash heads are to your subject will result in better and softer light.

Below is an example of a photo taken with a 550EX mounted on a cheap bracket to position it very close to the subject, and with an small reflector (cannibalised from a Cokin filter box) tied by elastic bands on the other side of the lens barrel to provide some fill. This is a very low tech and low cost solution to macro flash that produces some very pleasing and soft light. Obviously the further away from this rig the subject is, the less attractive the light becomes.

Soft flash

Macro flash, hand held @ F5.6

Another important consideration with macro photography is focal length: longer focal lengths give you much more control over the background. This is because at any given magnification, a longer lens will include less of the background in relation to the subject. So where a 50mm lens might make it difficult to control what background you have behind your subject without a great deal of repositioning, with a 300mm lens the smallest shift in position will radically change what is visible behind your subject.

I had harboured some concern about the Canon’s internal focusing mechanism which focuses closer by reducing the focal length of the lens. The advantage of this system is that the lens does not change shape when focusing, and remains constant in length all the way to 1:1. The obvious disadvantage is that a shorter focal length results in less background control, however since the Canon is a longer focal length than the Tamron at the outset it should still retain the advantage unless the IF reduces the focal length of the lens very drastically indeed.

The following image was taken at 1:2 magnification, with the remote control unit placed about 20 cm (8 inches) behind the ruler. The aperture was set to F32 to maximise the depth of field. As usual the Tamron sample is on the left and the Canon is on the right.

focal length comparison

focal length comparison @ 1:2

It seems that the IF does not shorten the focal length of the Canon lens too drastically, and that even at high magnification the focal length is still clearly longer than the Tamron's 90mm. The Canon lens includes less of the background than the Tamron does, so for background control the Canon is again at a slight advantage.

It is also worth noting that the Tamron lens focuses closer by extension, which means that the lens barrel lengthens as magnification increases, and it's length goes from 9cm (3.5 inches) at infinity to 14cm (5.5 inches) at 1:1. This does not affect the working distance mentioned earlier since I have measured this from the front end of the lens barrel, not from the film plane.

Compared to...

One caveat of testing lenses with a digital camera is that the limitations of the camera sensor will affect the test and subsequent results. It's possible for instance that one lens is actually much sharper than the other but that my camera simply isn't able to resolve enough detail to demonstrate this. However I know from my own experience that lens quality does indeed show up fairly obviously with the 10D. Whilst I do believe that both the lenses on test here are probably capable of outresolving my camera's sensor, I thought it would be of some benefit to compare the performance of these two excellent lenses against a potentially inferior model. Here is a shot which compares the two primes against a Canon 28-80 consumer zoom. The difference in quality is very apparent.

consumer lens comparison

Compared with a consumer 28-80 zoom @ F5.6

Conclusion

This exercise has surprised me somewhat in that I knew the Tamron lens was considered pretty good, but I did expect the Canon model to be significantly better. In this test at least, this hasn’t proven to be the case. Both lenses display excellent sharpness and contrast, and the only significant advantage the Canon has is in it’s vastly superior flare control. Other differences are fairly minor: the Canon lens has better saturation, more working distance and better AF – it is clearly a superior product – but the Tamron does very well to come so close (and to even surpass the Canon lens at high magnification) especially when you consider that it is up against one of Canon’s very best.

All in all I would say that in those places where the price of both lenses is fairly close the Canon is probably the better choice, but where there might be a significant price difference (such as in the UK where I live) then the Tamron is certainly worth considering since it delivers oustanding performance to rival and sometimes better it’s more expensive counterpart.